As the orchestra plays the bombastic sounds of a military march, missiles and artillery are proudly displayed in front of the gawking eyes of entranced citizens (as well as ally and enemy nations) who are inspired and frightened by such a show of military might. Calling this type of music use “exploitative” may be a misnomer, assuming that civilians and military officers are often supporting their own interests by supporting the military interests of their nations. Music may be exploitative, however, when its production is intended to elicit a costly emotional response in listeners, as would occur when populaces are manipulated into supporting doomed and self-destructive military campaigns by the propagandistic sounds of national anthems and jingoistic war songs. In this way, religious and nationalistic feeling (often the most lethal in combination) may be musically elicited by religious and political leaders whose aim is the extended phenotypic use of crowds and populations.

• Nevertheless, if group-directed transcendence can be evoked in a global society wherein members view all of humanity—and perhaps all sentient beings—as part of their ingroup, transcendence might be salvaged as an invaluable tool for creating and maintaining peace and well-being.
• Especially in the Christian tradition (wherein kinship terms are used to describe one’s relationship with the divine, as in “God the Father” in relation to His “children,” who are all “brethren”), transcendent states typified by filial piety are quite common.
• Having a transcendent purpose for their learning predicted participants’ scores on the self-control measures.
• Art Markman, Ph.D., is a cognitive scientist at the University of Texas whose research spans a range of topics in the way people think.

Wong identifies characteristics of self-transcendence as a shift in focus from self to other, a shift in our values from extrinsic to intrinsic, an increase in moral concern, and the experience of elevated emotions such as awe or ecstasy. Going further, Wong suggests that these experiences produce a spiral effect in which meaning, virtue, and happiness interact and cumulatively build. The role of parental deities as tools of manipulation is especially relevant in contexts of sudden religious conversion—an empirical indicator of a transcendent experience. In their meta-analysis, Granqvist and Kirkpatrick (2004) found that individuals with insecure attachments to parents were much more likely to experience sudden religious conversions. Although all such processes of informational synthesis speak to their adaptive design, knowledge structures are not always reflective of the true state of the world.

The study didn’t measure the quality of social interactions

This theory has mostly been accepted by the nursing community, and research has shown that self-transcendence plays an integral role in healing and in dignified acceptance of the end of life. This focus on self-transcendence in nursing came about when nurse and researcher Pamela Reed outlined her theory on the subject. Self-actualization is indeed a lofty (and worthy) goal of development and should not be cast aside in favor of the shiny new need, but self-transcendence is truly the “next level” of development; it is other-focused instead of self-focused and concerns higher goals than those which are self-serving. In this piece, we will define self-transcendence, look at its components and characteristics, think of some examples, and explore how it can be achieved. “We need to see more society-level interventions and support that make social connections easier, more likely, and of higher quality,” Foster said.

Bullet ants aside, fear is often elicited solely by the specific content of a religious or cultural tradition’s message. Often, the content will include reference to supernatural entities with their own minds, intentions, judgments, and powers of influence. An evolved system variously referred to as the “agency detector,” the “intentional stance,” and the “theory of mind” (ToM) is evoked during the processing of such supernatural content (Baron-Cohen 2005; Baron-Cohen et al. 1985; Dennett 1987). All of these describe mechanisms whose evolved function is the ready attribution of animacy to unknown sounds, sights, and sensations, the by-product of which is the occasional error of perceiving something inanimate as something animate. It is thought that by erring on the side of assuming that a rustling in the bushes, a shadowy movement in the grass, or an unexpected tingling on one’s skin is, in fact, a predator, human ancestors ensured their own survival and reproduction (Barrett 2000; Haselton and Buss 2000). Such sounds and sights were usually benign, but in case they were not, the immediate triggering of the fight-or-flight response would have saved an early human from an early grave.

Download 3 Free Meaning Tools Pack (PDF)

If we have a will to meaning, it follows within Wong’s theory that we would be seeking, finding, and experiencing “meaning of life.” In Wong’s theory, this is operationalized by a “meaning mindset” that enables us to find meaning and respond constructively to our experiences. May et al. (1960) and May (1983) what is transcendent-based quality defines “being” as the propensities within us that are continually emerging and becoming, that will stand out in time. He proposes that our self-awareness as human beings expands the range of our consciousness and thereby creates the situation in which we may transcend our immediate circumstances.

In an evolutionary reworking of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, Kenrick and Griskevicius (2013) amended Maslow’s famous developmental pyramid to more accurately reflect the emergence of adaptations that satisfy the biological needs of the individual. Whereas Maslow’s pyramid reaches its apex at “self-actualization” (i.e., the development of creativity, spontaneity, and moral sense), Kenrick and Griskevicius’ peaks at “kin care,” one of the final tasks that humans engage in to make sure that their genes outlive them. Leading up to kin care are the evolved needs for self-protection, disease avoidance, affiliation, status, mate acquisition, and mate retention, in order of developmental emergence. Although all of these “subselves” often co-occur with one another, individuals have to wait for either shorter or longer stretches of time before each comes to the fore, and some subselves may never manifest at all. So, for example, although our need for self-protection develops fairly early (e.g., even infants are wary of strangers; Sroufe 1977), it is not until we have children of our own that our kin care subself emerges. More pertinent to the current discussion, an individual might signal his cooperative and group-oriented qualities by exhibiting a costly emotional response that is hard to fake by cheaters.

His research has led him to believe that the magic of transcendence lies in its “annihilational” aspect, or the way it induces a feeling of self-loss. Neuroscience research shows that during transcendent states, there is decreased activity in the posterior superior parietal lobe, the area of the brain that locates the self in space and distinguishes it from everything else. When the neuronal inputs to this part of the brain decrease, the brain can no longer separate the self from the surrounding environment — which is why people feel their sense of self diminish, while also feeling connected to everyone and everything around them. The emphasis in the product-based approach is on quality as a precise and measurable variable. Any differences (in quality) that do occur reflect differences in the quantity of some ingredient or attribute possessed by a product. It consists of 15 items adapted from the Developmental Resources of Later Adulthood (DRLA) scale.

Religious definitions of transcendence, on the other hand, often emphasize the idea of connecting with something beyond the self or the material world, and may focus on concepts such as God, the soul, or the afterlife. These definitions are often grounded in faith and revelation, and may be seen as offering a way to access a higher or divine reality that cannot be directly observed or explained through reason alone. In religion, transcendence refers to the aspect of God’s nature and power which is wholly independent of the material universe, beyond all physical laws. This is contrasted with immanence, where a god is said to be fully present in the physical world and thus accessible to creatures in various ways.

He was able to put his own needs and interests aside and see the big picture and how he fits into it. The quintessential example of self-transcendence is undoubtedly Viktor Frankl’s experience in the concentration camps of World War II. It is also a unique context for self-transcendence, in that it is something that is possible, desirable, and achievable in a team context for both the patient and the nurse. It can act as both encouragement and inspiration for the patient to achieve wellness, and as motivation and purpose for the nurse is acting as a caregiver. Remember, this exercise is not an attempt to impress others, deliver a great performance or “improve the imperfect self”. Maslow’s addition of self-transcendence to the pyramid is not always noted in the literature when his theory is cited, but it has managed to make its way through the research community nonetheless.

The participants were asked questions about five different forms of social interaction. Two were subjective — how often they were able to confide in someone close to them and how often they felt lonely — and three were objective — how often friends and family visited, how often they participated in a weekly group activity, and whether they lived alone. This approach says that differences in quality can be viewed as the excess or deficiency of an attribute or trait in the product or service. Having a transcendent purpose for their learning predicted participants’ scores on the self-control measures. It also predicted the likelihood that students would do math problems rather than watch videos or play a game. Finally, the more that students had a purpose, the more likely they were to be enrolled in college in the Fall.